02 / The promise test

A promise deserves an outcome.

What was promised? What actually happened? Read the result, its scope and the official evidence for each selected commitment.

7 promises, tested one by one.

The tally covers these 7, not every promise a president made.

7 commitments reviewedAll administrations · selected records

Completed
3
Partial / limited
2
Not fulfilled as defined
2
Not verified
0

FROM A PLEDGE TO A FINDING

The test behind every label.

The same four questions apply to every selected commitment.

  1. 01

    The commitment

    Find the promise in an official record.

  2. 02

    The test

    Define what would count as delivery.

  3. 03

    The evidence

    Inspect dated actions and outcomes.

  4. 04

    The finding

    Read the status with its scope and limits.

Trump IIPartial / limited

No tax on tips

Evidence checkpoint: September 29, 2026

Illustration of a diner server receiving a cash tip beside a coffee cup
AI-generated editorial illustration · Tipped service work

What happened

The 2025 law created a federal income-tax deduction of up to $25,000 a year in qualified tips for eligible workers, for tax years 2025–2028. The IRS has issued filing guidance. This is a deduction from taxable income, not a $25,000 tax refund.

Scope of the relief

The deduction starts phasing out above $150,000 in modified adjusted gross income ($300,000 for joint filers). Occupation, qualifying-tip, reporting and filing rules apply. Social Security and Medicare taxes generally continue.

Assessment basis

Federal income-tax relief was enacted. The limited label describes its eligibility, amount and time limits; the cited pledge does not define a permanent exemption from every tax.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordTrump’s pre-enactment tax pledge: address to Congress (opens in a new tab)March 4, 2025 · Congressional Record, H969: calls for no tax on tips and no tax on overtime. A pre-enactment presidential statement, not the original 2024 campaign transcript.
Outcome evidenceIRS: Working Families Tax Cuts — individuals and workers (opens in a new tab)Accessed September 29, 2026 · Sections 70201–70202: qualified income, annual limits, 2025–2028 duration, income phaseouts and filing requirements.
Outcome evidenceIRS Publication 15 (2026): Employer’s Tax Guide (opens in a new tab)2026 edition · accessed September 29, 2026 · What’s New → Withholding on qualified tips / qualified overtime compensation: federal income-tax deductions; Social Security and Medicare taxes generally continue.
Outcome evidenceIRS guidance for 2025 tips and overtime deductions (opens in a new tab)November 21, 2025 · IR-2025-114: eligibility, caps, income phaseouts and FLSA overtime-premium examples.
Outcome evidenceFY2027 Budget: Governmental Receipts (opens in a new tab)April 2026 · Pages 74–75: temporary deductions and their limits.
Trump IIPartial / limited

No tax on overtime

Evidence checkpoint: September 29, 2026

Illustration of a technician working at a bench under a lamp at dusk
AI-generated editorial illustration · Overtime work

What happened

The 2025 law created a federal income-tax deduction of up to $12,500 a year ($25,000 for joint filers) in qualified overtime compensation for tax years 2025–2028. The IRS has issued filing guidance. These are deduction limits, not refund amounts.

Scope of the relief

Only the FLSA-required premium above regular pay qualifies—usually the extra half of time-and-a-half. The deduction starts phasing out above $150,000 in modified adjusted gross income ($300,000 for joint filers). Reporting and filing rules apply; Social Security and Medicare taxes generally continue.

Assessment basis

Federal income-tax relief was enacted. The limited label describes the qualifying pay, cap and duration; it is not a percentage score of campaign fulfillment.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordTrump’s pre-enactment tax pledge: address to Congress (opens in a new tab)March 4, 2025 · Congressional Record, H969: calls for no tax on tips and no tax on overtime. A pre-enactment presidential statement, not the original 2024 campaign transcript.
Outcome evidenceIRS: Working Families Tax Cuts — individuals and workers (opens in a new tab)Accessed September 29, 2026 · Sections 70201–70202: qualified income, annual limits, 2025–2028 duration, income phaseouts and filing requirements.
Outcome evidenceIRS Publication 15 (2026): Employer’s Tax Guide (opens in a new tab)2026 edition · accessed September 29, 2026 · What’s New → Withholding on qualified tips / qualified overtime compensation: federal income-tax deductions; Social Security and Medicare taxes generally continue.
Outcome evidenceIRS guidance for 2025 tips and overtime deductions (opens in a new tab)November 21, 2025 · IR-2025-114: eligibility, caps, income phaseouts and FLSA overtime-premium examples.
Outcome evidenceFY2027 Budget: Governmental Receipts (opens in a new tab)April 2026 · Pages 74–75: temporary deductions and their limits.
BidenNot fulfilled as defined

Cancel $10,000 of student debt for low- and middle-income borrowers

Evidence checkpoint: January 15, 2025

What happened

The Supreme Court blocked the broad program. Separate targeted relief reached millions of borrowers, but did not implement this program as designed.

Assessment basis

Deliver the broad $10,000 cancellation program, rather than announce it or count unrelated targeted relief.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordBiden student-loan pledge and proposed relief (opens in a new tab)August 24, 2022
Trump ICompleted

Place Neil Gorsuch on the Supreme Court

Evidence checkpoint: December 22, 2017

What happened

The year-one White House account identifies Gorsuch’s placement on the Court as a fulfilled campaign commitment.

Assessment basis

Nomination followed by confirmation and appointment, not nomination alone.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordTrump year-one campaign commitments (opens in a new tab)December 22, 2017
Trump ICompleted

Recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital

Evidence checkpoint: December 22, 2017

What happened

The White House records official recognition and explicitly links it to the campaign commitment.

Assessment basis

Official U.S. recognition. Moving the embassy is a separate action.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordTrump year-one campaign commitments (opens in a new tab)December 22, 2017
ObamaCompleted

Repeal Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell

Evidence checkpoint: September 20, 2011

What happened

The repeal law was signed in December 2010 and formally took effect on September 20, 2011.

Assessment basis

Legal repeal must take effect, not merely be signed.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordSigning the Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell Repeal Act (opens in a new tab)December 22, 2010 · Transcript: Vice President Biden identifies the campaign promise.
Outcome evidenceStatement on formal repeal (opens in a new tab)September 20, 2011
ObamaNot fulfilled as defined

Close the Guantánamo Bay detention facility

Evidence checkpoint: January 17, 2017

What happened

The White House acknowledged that closure would not be achieved before Obama left office. It reported 45 detainees on January 17, while citing congressional obstacles.

Assessment basis

Close the detention facility; reducing its population is not closure.

Open the pledge & outcome sources
Pledge identified in an official recordWhite House briefing on the closure pledge (opens in a new tab)January 12, 2017

Each record is counted once in its stated status. Partial / limited describes a narrower or incomplete result; not verified means the evidence is insufficient, not that the pledge failed. Labels are editorial assessments, not government grades. A historical completion label does not guarantee a policy remains in force today.